Step 1: Ingredient-label review
We read the International Nomenclature of Cosmetic Ingredients (INCI) list: cleansing agents, silicone types, proteins, humectants and fragrance. Ingredients are listed in descending order of concentration above 1%, which tells us what a formula is mostly made of.
Step 2: Hair type and need
A formula that suits fine, straight hair can weigh down coily hair. We match products to hair types and concerns:
- Straight & fine: weight, oil build-up, volume and heat protection.
- Wavy: frizz control, bounce and wash-day length.
- Curly & coily: moisture retention, definition and detangling slip.
- Colour-treated & bleached: gentle cleansing and strength.
Step 3: Evidence and buyer feedback
Where published research exists we cite it. For most consumer products it does not, so we also weigh the volume and consistency of verified buyer reviews, and we note when feedback is mixed.
Step 4: Price and value
We compare each pick with cheaper alternatives. If a drugstore option does the same job, we say so. Prices change often, so check the retailer page before buying.
What we do not claim
HairDuty is an independent editorial site, not a laboratory or clinic. We do not claim that every product listed has been physically tested by us, and nothing here is medical advice. For hair loss, persistent itching, pain or skin changes, please see a doctor or dermatologist. Many links on the site are affiliate links; see our affiliate disclosure.